#just this completely unexpected swerve that threw off his plan and put dean (and sam) in the line of fire
Explore tagged Tumblr posts
Text
one thing that always makes me ???? about the pilot is john's motel room.
he left his photo of him and the boys, he left his journal which the cops got, he left his freaking jacket. literally did not take the clothes jacket off his back. which is.... ????
if the demons (i.e., azazel and co) were literally on his ass to the extent that he had to drop everything, like everything, and run, wouldn't he have maybe given a heads up to sam and dean that Danger Was Imminent? or was he so entirely confident that they wouldn't be targeted and that only he himself was in danger, so he actually did drop everything and run but felt fine not even leaving a voicemail?
(if he thought that, uhhhh, just looking at jess, over here, and not saying anything).
like i get the narrative reason and function, but with all that in mind, the in-universe explanation that i land on is pretty much that john deliberately made it look like he had to drop everything and run. that he was in imminent, immediately, life-threatening danger, and this charade was mostly for dean. the logic of which is just... wild.
#john is a bit unhinged#thoughts and comments welcome#like did he think he was in that much danger?#but if so maybe let the boy(s) know?#and i know he was trying to keep them out of it but how is disappearing without a trace#going to *not* make dean go to the exact motel room you were last seen at?#which could make him inadvertently cross paths with the exact demons on your trail?#which loops me back around to john believing that the demons wouldn't hurt dean#and i guess maybe that john being so deep underground that even dean can't reach him#makes him think dean wouldn't be taken hostage by demons to smoke him out of hiding#which is a freaking gamble my dude#tbh i think dean going to get sam was a huge wildcard for john#just this completely unexpected swerve that threw off his plan and put dean (and sam) in the line of fire#sam was in the line of fire anyway though#john was probably just lying to himself thinking he could stop the YED before sam got hurt#anyway#my meta#phyn rambles#phyn rambles in the tags#pilot
51 notes
·
View notes